PART 1 — THE GIRL IN THE WINDOW
THE TWO RABBITS
Another flash of lightning lit up the room across the street. The mysterious girl was holding something against her chest. A white rabbit. With a lavender ear. Claire looked down. Lily was still hugging hers. The two looked identical. "She has one just like mine," Lily whispered. Claire took her daughter’s stuffed toy and examined it. "Yours is right here." "Then why does she have one just like it?" Ethan moved even closer to the window. Too fast. Claire noticed. "Ethan." He didn’t answer. "Do you know that toy?" Her husband took a step back. "No." Claire knew him too well. "You just lied to me." Ethan closed his eyes. Outside, the rain kept pounding the glass. Finally, he spoke. "I used to live in that house." Claire thought she had misheard. "What?" "When I was a boy." She looked at the house. Then at her husband. They had been married for twelve years. "You never told me that." "I know." "Ethan, we’ve lived across the street from it for four years." "That’s precisely why I never wanted to talk about it." Claire frowned. "That doesn’t make any sense." "It does to me."
"MY SISTER HAD ONE JUST LIKE IT"
Lily looked out the window again. The girl across the street lowered the rabbit. Then she pointed gently toward Lily. Lily stepped back. "Mom... she’s pointing at me." Claire pulled her close. "Stay with me." Ethan stared at the stuffed animal. "Move her a little away from the window." Claire obeyed, but didn't take her eyes off him. "What is wrong with you?" Ethan took a deep breath. "That rabbit..." "What about it?" "My sister had one exactly like it." Silence. It took Claire several seconds to react. "Your sister?" Ethan nodded. "You never told me you had a sister." "My family stopped talking about her many years ago." "What was her name?" Ethan looked toward the house. "Rebecca."
REBECCA CARTER
Ethan was nine years old when he lived in that house. Rebecca was eleven. They were inseparable. Rebecca was the brave one. Ethan was the one who always followed her lead. Their mother, Margaret Carter, had bought two nearly identical stuffed rabbits. One for Rebecca. Another for a girl who frequently visited the house. "What girl?" Claire asked. Ethan shook his head. "That’s the problem." "You don’t remember?" "I remember her face. I remember her playing with Rebecca. But for years, no one would tell me who she was." Claire pointed to the house across the street. "Is she the girl in the photograph you mentioned?" Ethan looked at her, surprised. "How do you know about the photo?" "Because when you saw that girl, you said she looked like someone." Ethan remained silent. Then he nodded.
THE PHOTOGRAPH
When Ethan was eight years old, his father took a photograph in front of that house. Rebecca was in the yard. Beside her was another girl. Both held those rabbits. "Were they identical?" "Almost. Rebecca’s had a lavender ear. The other one did too." "And what happened to the photograph?" "My mother put it away." "And what about Rebecca?" Ethan took a moment to answer. "She left." "Where?" "They never told me." Claire looked at him in disbelief. "Your sister disappeared, and you all simply stopped talking about her?" "I was a child." "But then you grew up." "And every time I asked, my father changed the subject." "Your mother?" "She would cry." Claire lowered her voice. "Did Rebecca die?" "I don’t know." That answer was much worse than Claire had expected.
THE CLOSED HOUSE
After Rebecca disappeared from Ethan’s life, the family moved away. The house was handed down to a relative. Years later, it was left empty. No one ever lived there permanently again. When Ethan returned to that town as an adult, he avoided the street for years. Until Claire found a house for sale. Right across from it. "And you bought our house knowing that place was right here?" "Yes." "Why?" Ethan looked at the old facade. "Because I thought maybe one day I’d find out what happened." Claire observed him. That changed everything. Ethan hadn’t chosen this neighborhood by chance. He had come back looking for an answer.
LILY’S RABBIT
Claire looked at her daughter’s toy. "Where did this rabbit come from?" "From my mother." Claire remembered. Margaret had given it to Lily for her sixth birthday. She had said she found it tucked away among old family belongings. Ethan picked up the stuffed animal. He examined the stitching. The lavender ear. A small repair near one paw. The color drained from his face. "Claire..." "What?" "This isn’t just a rabbit that looks like Rebecca’s." Lily looked at him. "What do you mean?" Ethan swallowed hard. "This was Rebecca’s rabbit."
THE CALL TO MARGARET
Ethan grabbed his phone. He called his mother. Margaret answered on the fourth ring. "Ethan, are you all okay with the flooding?" "Yes. We’re upstairs." "Thank God." "Mom, I need to ask you something." Margaret recognized her son’s tone. "What’s wrong?" "The rabbit you gave Lily." Silence. "What about it?" "It belonged to Rebecca." Margaret didn't answer. "Mom." "Ethan, now is not the time." "Why did you have it?" "We’ll talk after the storm passes." "No." Ethan looked at the house across the street. The girl was still there. "There’s someone inside the house." Margaret stopped breathing for a second. "Which house?" "Ours." "Ethan..." "There's a little girl at the window." Margaret’s voice changed. "Listen to me. Do not cross the street." "We couldn't even if we wanted to." "Do not try to go into that house." Claire stepped closer. "Why is she so terrified?" Ethan switched to speakerphone. "Mom, the girl has another rabbit." Margaret fell silent. Then she asked: "A lavender ear?" Ethan looked at Claire. "Yes." Margaret began to cry.
"THERE WERE TWO"
"Mom, tell me the truth." Margaret struggled to breathe. "There were two rabbits." "I already know that." "No, Ethan. You don’t understand. They weren't bought from a store. Your grandmother made them by hand." Ethan looked at the stitching. "For Rebecca and for whom?" Margaret didn't answer. "Mom!" "For Rebecca and Anna." Ethan felt something inside him stop. "Who was Anna?" "The girl in the photograph." "I know that too. Who was she?" Margaret began to sob harder. "Ethan, forgive me." "Why?" "Because we let you grow up believing Rebecca was your only sister."
THE SECOND GIRL
Claire put a hand over her mouth. Ethan couldn't speak for several seconds. "Anna was my sister?" Margaret replied: "Yes." Ethan closed his eyes. "Why didn’t you ever tell me?" "Because it was complicated." "Don’t tell me it was complicated." "Your father..." "What did my father do?" "Anna didn't live with us." "Why?" Margaret took a deep breath. "Because she was born before your father and I got married." Ethan understood. Anna was his father’s daughter with another woman. His half-sister. Rebecca knew. That was why they played together. That was why they appeared in photographs. That was why there were two rabbits.
THE DAY EVERYTHING CHANGED
Margaret explained that Rebecca had discovered the truth when she was eleven years old. She wanted Anna to be openly acknowledged as part of the family. Ethan’s father refused. He feared the scandal. He feared Margaret would leave him. He feared everyone would find out he had hidden a daughter. Rebecca was furious. "And then what?" Margaret remained silent. "What happened to Rebecca?" "She left with Anna and Anna’s mother for a while." "And she never came back?" "She did come back." Ethan opened his eyes. "When?" "Years later." "Why didn’t I ever see her?" Margaret was weeping. "Because your father wouldn't allow it."
SOMETHING MOVES IN THE HOUSE OPPOSITE
Lily tugged at Claire’s sleeve. "Mom." Claire looked. The girl across the street was no longer alone. An adult figure appeared behind her. A woman. Only for a moment. Then she stepped away from the window. Ethan felt his heart pounding in his chest. "There’s someone else." Margaret asked quickly: "A woman?" "Yes." "What does she look like?" "I can’t see her clearly." Margaret fell silent. "Mom... do you know who’s in there?" "No." But Ethan heard a lie once again.
THE SIGN
The girl raised the rabbit again. She moved it twice to the left. Then once to the right. Ethan stood frozen. "It can’t be." Claire looked at him. "What?" "Rebecca used to do that." "Do what?" "When we were kids and our parents grounded us, we used to communicate from our rooms using toys. Two to the left, one to the right." "What did it mean?" Ethan stared at the girl. "'Look underneath.'"
UNDERNEATH THE RABBIT
Ethan examined Lily’s stuffed animal. Underneath one paw, he found a more recent seam. He didn't want to tear it open. But he felt something hard inside. A small object. Claire brought a pair of sewing scissors. They snippet it open just a couple of inches. Inside was a tiny key. And a folded piece of paper. Margaret was still on the line. When she heard that they had found something, she began to plead. "Ethan, don’t open it." He held still. "Why?" "Because Rebecca asked me not to give it to you until she was ready." Ethan felt his hands shaking. "Is Rebecca alive?" Margaret didn't answer. "Mom." Silence. "Is Rebecca alive?" "The last I heard from her... yes."
THE NOTE
Ethan unfolded the paper. There was only one sentence. "If you ever see the second rabbit in the window, it means Anna has returned home." Ethan looked across the street. The girl was still there. Holding the second rabbit. Claire whispered: "Then that girl..." "She can’t be Anna. She’d be over forty years old." "Then who is she?" Ethan turned back to his mother on the phone. "Mom, did Anna have a daughter?" Margaret didn't reply. That was answer enough.
THE FACE BEHIND THE GLASS
A flash of lightning illuminated the house. The adult woman appeared once more. This time, Ethan saw her face. The air seemed to leave the room. "Ethan," Claire said. "What is it?" He walked up close to the glass. The woman on the other side did the same. Her hair was shorter. Wrinkles surrounded her eyes. But Ethan recognized her. Not because she looked identical to his memories, but because he had spent thirty years trying not to forget her. "Rebecca..." Claire looked at him. "Is she your sister?" Ethan didn't answer. Across the street, the woman raised a hand. The exact same gesture she made when they were children. Ethan pressed his hand against his own window pane. Two houses. A street turned into a river. Thirty years. And between them, a truth no one had wanted to tell.
May you like
THE FINAL QUESTION
Ethan spoke back into the phone. "Mom." Margaret was sobbing. "I’m so sorry." "Rebecca is over there." "I know." Ethan froze. "What do you mean, you know?" Margaret didn't answer. "Did you know she had come back?" "Yes." "For how long?" "For three weeks." Ethan felt a rush of anger. "Three weeks?" "She asked me for time." "I’ve been waiting for thirty years!" "Ethan..." "And the little girl?" Margaret took a deep breath. "The girl’s name is Grace." "Who is she?" "That part, Rebecca has to tell you herself." "Mom!" Margaret answered through tears: "Because if I tell you who Grace is, I’ll also have to explain why Rebecca really disappeared... and why your father made the whole family swear we would never tell you that the girl standing beside your sister in that photograph was..." The call cut out. Ethan looked at his phone. Then he slowly raised his eyes. Rebecca was still at the window. And Grace held up the second rabbit.
